Proposed Historic WW-II Naval Air Station Barbers Point Housing District A Decimated, Fire Drill Ghost Town
by John Bond
When the Navy began the BRAC (Base Realignment And Closure) process in the late 1990's, a series of expensive historic, archeological and environmental studies were commissioned to determine as much as possible what was there that should be remediated and what should be preserved for future generations.
Before and After (1980's photo and 2013 photo)
Keep in mind, WW-II was a major historic point in American history, NAS Barbers Point was built back in the wartime territorial era, and due to the war effort significant structures were designed by major, important architects and engineers of that period that worked without the usual big fees and commissions to design very exceptional buildings.
Two areas in the NAS Barbers Point were identified as historic districts that would preserve some of the key WW-II features and the historic, cultural landscape that would have been found by future visitors to the civilianized former Navy base. A chance to look back in time in what would otherwise be a sea of the usual West Oahu high density urban sprawl now taking place.
One area was designated as the NAS Barbers Point Central Core Historic District Boundary. This includes the WW-II hangars, control tower, fire station, parachute loft and a few other structures.
The other area was designated as the WW-II Housing Area Historic District Boundary. This area included some of the last best specimens of classic WW-II home design for senior naval officers who commanded air wings and operational base assets. These Hawaiian tropical designs had big yards, large canopy trees, great walkway hedges, Singapore plumeria trees, etc.
Page 290 of major Navy BRAC document showing proposed historic districts...
Unfortunately, once HCDA (Hawaii Community Development Authority) got their hands on former Naval Air Station Barbers Point and it became "Kalaeloa," the whole place largely all went to hell, -except for the main State Airport parcel.
Historic buildings that were supposed to be preserved and infrastructure that was supposed to be protected wasn't. Fortunately because some buildings became part of the Kalaeloa State Airport and had high security fencing around them- which along with September 11, 2001 heightened airport security, caused the historic former Navy airport buildings to receive adequate security protection.
While significant amounts of Kalaeloa looting and arson took place after the closure, which could have been prevented with a reasonably small investment in combined Navy and civilian security patrols with HPD cooperation, that apparently never happened. Many very fine former Navy buildings- homes, barracks, clubs, etc. were smashed, looted and grafittied in every way possible.
Now it unfortunately appears that the fine specimens of senior WW-II naval aviator homes aren't collapsing and screaming for obvious demolition as was hoped for, so they are being assisted in their demise by having holes hacked in their roof tops. (What an eyesore! We must knock them down!)
Some of the historic WW-II homes with hacked roofs. The last photo indicates that the local fire department may have been given these homes to use to conduct practice drills...
This isn't vandalism, this appears as very methodical and designed to cause as much interior damage as possible through weathering effects. Those who have seen this technique before know that this is how the Navy has "dealt with" historic buildings around Pearl Harbor before- open all the windows, don't do the most simple things to protect anything from the weather, make sure no grass is cut, and maybe some "creative" pre-demolition work might also take place. (What an eyesore! We must knock them down!)
The Navy certainly hasn't authorized this to be done at former NAS Barbers Point because frankly they don't care anymore about what happens there at all. They have made that very clear, even though they are actually technically still the land owners of this property. Selling it off would require a process called a Federal Section 106, which can be a big pain- so if the historic assets can be made to "degrade" and just "go away" that just makes everything that much easier.
This entire Kalaeloa area comes under the "protective" domain of the Hawaii Community Development Authority (HCDA) which is only interested in real estate development and the profits to be made if this WW-II historic district could be made to just disappear, as has been happening with no one paying any attention...
Note the number of dying off trees from a couple of years ago compared to this 2013 photo below:
In this WW-II Historic District area only one home is still occupied (circled in red) - the former home of the commander of the naval air station. This shows how these classic historic homes could have been maintained and put on the rent or lease market rather than being destroyed through intentional neglect...
Below are photos taken before Naval Air Station Barbers Point closed, probably in the late 80's or early 90's, of these home interiors that have no doubt by now been completely looted...
These photos are part of a Library of Congress collection done back when the Federal government still had budgets for such things and still cared about historic Federal property owned by the tax payers. This rarely happens anymore, especially out in "Kalaeloa."
And here's what they look like today, in 2013 - (What an eyesore! We must knock them down!)
BRAC - Base Realignment And Closure at it's finest...Your Federal property TRASHED.
